Monday, February 20, 2012

I'm going to go out on a limb and make one of the most insightful statements ever:

Social media and broadcasting through the internet has helped musicians, actors, athletes, and media franchises expand their horizons unlike any other period in history.

Well I'm sure you don't need me telling you that but this recently came up to my attention because I'm an avid soccer/football/joga bonito (call it what you want) fan. However, I live in the United States where games aren't easily accessible. This usually requires me waking up at around 7 in the morning each Saturday to watch my favorite teams play. The added challenge is that they're usually not on TV so I have to live stream it from providers. The best streams came from a site called FirstRowSports. Each Saturday I would woke up and watched a pretty good quality stream of the game in English commentary, the main attraction of the game. Not to mention it helped me catch some American football games that were "out-of-market."

Why do I mention this? Well, I tried to watch a UEFA Champions League match the other day and found that the domain had been seized by the Federal Government. Why? Apparently, the website was broadcasting the Super Bowl illegally. At first I was confused and thought about the reasons why they would seize the domain. I couldn't think of many good ones. In fact I found some reasons why an action like that would be illegal.

1. FirstRowSports doesn't operate in the US exclusively. It doesn't even have a .com ending (I don't know the technical term). It wasn't in the UK, Germany, or any other country. It was just merely a worldwide source with its own domain enabling people to watch not only English Premier League games, but also other sports like table tennis, rugby, tennis, and some NFL games as well. The federal government justified the seizure with the ACTA bill. Now this should have only applied to people here and not everywhere but there were some irritated people from Europe who wanted to watch out of market football matches and were suddenly unable to.
2. Secondly, this was done over complaints about broadcasting the Super Bowl. I find this one to be quite irrational. The Super Bowl is a great event because it not only attracts millions of viewers in the US, but also gives companies a great opportunity to pay millions to get 30 seconds of ad time and expand their production capabilities. In Europe for instance, most countries found absolutely no problem with the broadcast of the Premier League or the UEFA Champions League across the world. In fact they almost encourage it and regularly boast viewerships 8-10 times the amount that the Super Bowl gets and many times the revenue. FirstRowSports promoted global viewership of European leagues and garnered widespread interest. Does it matter to the leagues if a few million people get access to their games without paying if it means they can increase marketing opportunities? No, so why should the Super Bowl, which is pretty much an exclusive American thing, be limited to within our borders if the goal is to spread American football to other parts of the world too? Will viewers in the UK be willing to make that trip to Wembley to watch two of our average teams play in front of them and market the game? Probably not. It's a marketing opportunity gone to waste.
3. Nothing about the business model seemed sketchy. In the whole midst of the SOPA and PIPA outrage, the website said that viewership was entirely free and the costs for the streams were compensated for by ad time in the form of pop-ups. The pop-ups were a minor inconvenience but we were ultimately entertained. So what's the big problem?

Granted they maybe embellished it a bit to keep the stream going, but who cares? Who is really hurt by this.

The basis behind the protection of artists' intellectual property, the media's revenue sources, and sponsorship interests is one argument behind the recent crackdown on free things in the internet. The idea is that if these sellers of entertainment aren't maximizing revenue, there would be a lower incentive to maintain the high quality standards we've come to expect from them.

I think this argument is totally unfounded. It seems fundamentally sound because people are motivated by incentives but if they're going to argue about incentives I'll argue about margins. In the grand scheme of things, if musical artists are entitled to let's say 10 million dollars from the amount of records sold, would they be absolutely crushed if the amount lost to free downloads was about 2 million? Probably not. Free downloads do not constitute the majority of artist revenues so far so even though there is some money lost, it still lacks marginal value to the artist in question. If their utility depends on that extra 2 million then maybe there will be some artists who will exit. But the market is free and there are millions of people who would gladly sell their music for a fraction of what those artists make. The same can definitely be said of the media in sports ventures. NBC made extravagant amounts of cash this year from the Super Bowl, in the hundreds of millions from ads. If a million people in Australia watched the game for free, would it kill their source of revenues? No, would they file for bankruptcy? No

As for the streaming of soccer games, I'll keep on finding them. For every stream that gets shut down, there will definitely be one that replaces it albeit if not at the same quality. When I buy my own place, then I'll subscribe to GolTV, FoxSoccer, and others because as of right now television is the best medium for games still, other than the stadium. What are your thoughts.

Friday, January 6, 2012

Happy New Year

People are saying this is the year that the US economy will make the most progress. Many analysts from Bloomberg news are predicting that financial markets will have their best year in 5 years and that the unemployment rate will drop pretty dramatically Almost akin to the 1982 economic recovery after a near decade of stagflation.

However, the US still has spending issues and Congress's inability to reach a consensus on the debt limit is slightly worrying. Our credit score was dropped in August by Standard and Poor because of our government's incompetence. Keynesian economics says that the more we spend the better we do, and while I believe that it works to an extent I don't think it's a good long term solution. While everyone agrees that corporate loopholes must be removed in order to raise more in taxes, some members of congress want additional tax increases and others want cuts in major spending initiatives and tax cuts.

The dilemma we are now faced with is if we should make a compromise in order to cut spending in a crucial growth year or evaluate our progress.

I say we should. I know there's an argument which points to countries who can survive with debt of 200% of GDP (like Japan) and how for years Ireland was pretty much unfazed by their debt of 950%. While the United States isn't in as dire a position as Ireland, the amount of debt we have is making many people uneasy particularly because of our economic influence.

My reasoning is that even though Keynesian policy would say cutting spending or raising taxes will cause a recession, there have been instances when the United States has used both options and seen economic growth unchanged, particularly during Ronald Reagan's era. He was known as the tax cutter but he accepted compromises and ended up with contracting fiscal policy despite one of the best eras of growth. Then of course Reagan proceeded to lower taxes and expand growth further.

After all we can't have our cake and eat it too. It's one or the other.

Meanwhile in Europe, the outlook is increasingly bleak as Germany is one of the few countries experiencing solid growth and the responsibility of the Euro has seemed to fall on them. Germany now has Portugal to add to the list of indebted nations and the Euro seems to be doomed for collapse and some are saying that it would make everyone better off.

I didn't like the concept of the Euro because it involved uniting strong industrial, exporting nations who could afford a strong currency with importing nations who weren't as influential on the global scale. Germany could have transitioned to the Euro, Netherlands could have accepted the Euro. Italy, Spain, Portugal, and Greece were not capable of accepting a strong currency because they were largely importing nations and their former currencies were a lot weaker in comparison.

However, transitioning back to pre-Euro times is not a good idea because that would cause a massive international default on debts and considering the size of the Eurozone, that would plunge the global economy into a hellish scenario. China's growth would be radically compromised, the US dollar would experience deflation and throw the whole growth process in reverse, and global demand would fall tremendously as these recently absolved nations would have to erase all growth created in the past decade. So I say the Euro has to stick around and the indebted nations will have to deal with the poison of austerity cuts in the meantime figuring out other alternatives to bolster domestic economic growth. As much as it would hurt the people in the Eurozone, they all would have to make severe cuts to healthcare, education, and other subsidized programs which could eat up into their budgets. As a collective currency, and I know Germany will not like this, they all have to hold each other up and take blows for each other. It's a major punishment to the countries who have followed their debt regulations and kept spending in check but they have to accept the consequences. In many ways the Euro had to act like a cartel but as with any oligopoly, the more members there are, the harder it is to collude especially as they each have different interests.

Thursday, October 6, 2011

This year it seems as though revolution after revolution keeps on taking place somewhere in the world. First it started in North Africa and spread rapidly across the Middle East. For the most part, the movements in the Middle East were for democracy and heightened due to economic woes and social inequality, so I could see where the protesters were coming from.

However, the latest protest in New York, "The Occupy Wall Street movement" to me seems entirely ridiculous for 2 big reasons: It's extremely short sighted with its generic demands that are, in truth, unrealistic to accomplish, and that they are targeting the wrong people

1. I'll start with the their demands. The main goal of the Occupy Wall Street is to end government corruption by asking the President to create an oversight committee to monitor lobbying. That's really cool and original, did they think of that themselves? I mean it's such an innovative concept that will surely accomplish a lot and revolutionize the way we support our government and our political leaders.

Sarcasm aside, this is not a new thought and it's too general. It sounds like they haven't fully thought through how effective a committee would be. Let's face it, most Congressional members are non-cooperative with opposing party members. So let's imagine that the President decides to act on this protest and he forms a bipartisan committee. In order to be fair, the bipartisan committee would have to have an equal number of Democrats and Republicans despite the fact that Republicans have a majority. What would likely happen is that Democrats will target Republican representatives for catering to special interests and vice versa. Strategically speaking, these bipartisan members will reject claims about lobbying when it concerns members of their own party so that they can have leverage when it comes to voting on important issues.

2. They are targeting the wrong people. Congratulations protesters, you have determined that Wall Street executives and their respective firms have received $1.5 trillion from the bailouts in 2008 and 2009. Obviously this must mean that they are hoarding money from the government because they have a lot of influence on the government.

Now for the serious part. Yes, the government paid AIG and other Wall Street firms a lot of our taxpayer money and it is difficult to imagine what would have happened had the government decided not to bail them out. Some say the banks are too big to fail, and others say that we should have let them rot and gamble with the potential repercussions. But to say that Wall Street can basically hold the government to ransom is dogmatic and misinformed.

There are several executives across a wide domain of industries who lobby politicians such as environmentalists, oil executives, energy executives, labor unions, trade unions, health, miscellaneous businesses, etc. In fact, the Finance, Real Estate, and Insurance lobby constitutes just 14% of all lobbyist spending between 1998 and 2010 while health, communications, and natural resources together constitute over a third of lobbyist spending in that same time frame.

Finance isn't even the lone reason behind the spending. Real Estate was buoyed by the 2000s housing bubble so naturally a lobby would be able to spend a decent amount to prevent restrictive laws. Insurance has been steadily escalating its premiums and policies over the past decade due to adverse selection and moral hazard so even if there were movements to stop their influence, the insurance companies would be more than able to deal with that. So if the Occupy Wall Street movement is going to target the Financial sector, they should be willing to put an offshoot movement and target other major lobbying sectors like healthcare and energy because they too contribute a lot. 14% is a small part of the puzzle and while eliminating that kind of influence is a good thing, it doesn't really stop the overall presence of lobbying.

So while Occupy Wall Street can help some frustrated people vent their frustrations out on some bigger organization, it won't solve anything because they'll realize that all their economic woes are not caused by Wall Street. While several firms on Wall Street did fail disastrously during the 2000's, there are deeper problems that we are not recognizing and targeting one particular organization for what they did in the past is no guarantee that we will have a better future.

Monday, July 18, 2011

Federal spending has gone through the roof in the past decade given the extended conflicts in the middle east and the prolonged global recession. In fact, spending has gone so high that we are in danger of not being able to pay back our debts. We have about 15 days before the United States Federal government will default on its debt. That is, unless Congress agrees to raise the debt ceiling which gives us some time to start lowering our debt.

Defaulting on debt is a horrible process to go through and we're seeing Portugal, Greece, Ireland, and Spain having to undergo serious austerity cuts. When their governments defaulted, the recessions in their respective countries worsened and fueled more negative speculation in global markets. Not to downplay the importance of their economies, but Ireland was the only country experiencing significant growth prior to the recession.

If the United States defaults, the global economy will enter an extremely dire situation on several fronts.

1. No one will be able to bail them out----When Greece defaulted, the International Monetary Fund and the European Union combined to give them an initial bailout. A significant part of the money from the IMF side of the 110 billion euro bailout was funded by the US. The US economy is the largest as an individual country and much larger than Spain, Greece, Ireland, and Portugal combined so if the public debt and deficit percentage are too high, it would take a serious combined effort from the EU, China and India to give us some help but their economies would be too adversely affected from a US default that they would have to stretch their resources just to keep the global economy stable
2. The IMF and World Bank would lose serious legitimacy--- These two institutions are primarily responsible for creating a global banking reserve, but the United States was a chief contributor and should another crisis emerge elsewhere around the world, neither institution would gather enough cash to bail them out.
3. Commodities would have to find a new currency to trade in---The only apparently stable currency to trade different commodities is the Chinese Yuan (RMB). However, the Yuan is not too popular because it is currently pegged to the US$ and a default crisis would cause sever instability of the US$. The Yuan also suffers from inflation within China that is repressed in the statistics because of their fixed exchange rate. The Euro is currently in its own series of upswings and downswings due to their own continental crisis. The pound is not a good currency to trade in because it is such a powerful currency and not as involved as the US$, the Euro, or the Yuan. Not to mention, commodity prices will rapidly shoot up in the US and in other countries.
4. US trading partners will see a large downturn---This is a huge negative because a lot of developing nations export several goods to the US and some developed countries like Japan and Canada will see a drastic downturn in global demand for their goods because the US is their top foreign consumer. China's rapid growth rate will slow down significantly due to the lack of demand around the world and a loss of confidence in the global economy.
5. Foreign Aid will be setback several years--- Although foreign aid makes up a whopping 0.7% of US GDP, it's not their contributions alone that will be affected. The nations who actively provide aid will have to cut back on theirs just to stop their own debt after bailing the US out. As a result, potential conflict could break out and the democratic revolutions that have occurred this year could revert back to their previous oppressive dictatorships.

There are of course several other implications behind a US default but let's just hope that congress can come together one time to help us out. I'll publish a list of things the US should do to avoid having to raise the debt limit again and continuing the cycle.

Friday, May 20, 2011

It is no secret.

Me and several of my friends are attending private colleges because they have programs that are highly ranked in newspapers, world class professors who have won Nobel Prizes, well established connections in the job markets, and the respect that comes along with attending these schools. There is only one drawback though

Cost.

Virtually all of the top schools in the country have tuition rates in the mid 30,000s per year like the University of Michigan (Out of state), UPenn, Stanford, Harvard and Princeton. Some are in the mid 40s such as Cornell, Columbia, CMU, Georgetown, and the University of Chicago to name a few. All of these schools are well respected and have produced some revolutionary graduates who have contributed positively to the world in some form or another. But as tuition rates rise at an astounding rate, the question comes to play whether or not going to a well-esteemed school is worth the debt. Not only is getting into these schools becoming a challenge but attending them and paying the steep financial cost will be the next filter.

Graduates from these schools, assuming they don't get any financial aid whatsoever, will have over $200,000 in undergraduate debts and people who want to attend graduate school will have an additional $100,000 in debt for Masters/MBA programs. After interest is added up, it would likely take between 10 and 15 years to pay off such a large debt. Our generation will likely scrimp and save more than any generation has ever done before and college costs will be as big a commitment as mortgage and car payments if tuition keeps sky rocketing like it has done for the past two decades. If our generation does not consume as much as it should due to college costs, we will face a huge ordeal of problems in the near future as governments everywhere will struggle to pay for the pension and healthcare burden senior citizens will place on them.

But on the positive side, I highly doubt college education costs will rise to that degree to cause massive economic problems in the future. People's attitudes towards the elite colleges will change in the near future. Employers will eventually realize on a broad level that some of their brightest candidates did not go to an Ivy league school and they are starting to put less weight towards a degree from the Ivies. I think that when people understand that an elite college degree does not set them apart as much as it used to, they will eventually turn away from the steep financial prospects placed on them and they will apply to any school that values their intelligence enough to give them a scholarship. When application fees to the elite colleges drop, only then will they realize that they have to entice the public to get a degree from their university and tuition rates will become slightly more reasonable but not enough so that we won't be in debt. For my generation, it might be a little bit too late but for future college applicants, where you go doesn't determine how good you are in life. In the end you have to be the one that makes the most out of a degree. It is true that going to one of the elite colleges sets you slightly apart but it won't be worth the debt.